February 18, 2005

Commentary:

Something to think about...

    By Jack Grant

...as the Baby Boomers age:

Woman refuses to leave the hospital
82-year-old was discharged a year ago, officials say

The Associated Press
Updated: 7:10 p.m. ET Feb. 16, 2005

More than a year after Sarah Nome was deemed healthy and given her discharge papers, the 82-year-old woman stubbornly refuses to leave her hospital bed.


Sounds like an amusing story, no?

But wait, there's more to it:

Nome admits there is no reason she should be racking up unpaid medical bills - which have now topped $1 million - but says she has nowhere else to turn.

Now Kaiser Permanente's San Rafael Medical Center in California is suing her for the cost of her stay and trying to show her the door.


Well, they should, given that she's healthy,

But wait, there's more to it:

"The thing is, I have no medical problem. I've been here more than a year, never had any medication, never had any treatment, never had a fever, have a perfect heart, blood pressure is like a teenager," Nome said in a telephone interview from the hospital north of San Francisco. "It isn't that I'm not ready to go. I just have nowhere to go."

...

Nome's troubles began, her daughter Jane Sands says, in 2002 when she broke both her legs while living alone. After several operations, Nome could no longer care for herself and was admitted to the first of several nursing homes.

The most recent one, Nome claims, sent her to the hospital against her will. Hospital officials say she was admitted for a weeklong psychiatric evaluation, was deemed to be in good mental health, was then ordered released.

But because she is suing the nursing homes where she lived before she was hospitalized, Nome and her daughter claim she has no choice but to stay put. Nome is suing the last home she lived in, Greenbrae Care Center, for sending her to the hospital.


OK, NOW we get to something that may indicate a larger issue at hand...

Anthony Wright, executive director of the health care advocacy group Health Access California, said Nome's situation highlights a larger, nationwide problem.

"This issue is becoming more and more contentious because ... we don't have a long-term care policy in this country, so there is no set way that we take care of seniors who need ongoing care," he said.


At one time, there used to be a concept in this country of the "extended family" where people felt obliged to take care of their relatives, whether parents, uncles and aunts, great uncles and great aunts, occasionally cousins, and so on.

Now, that concept has been swept into the dustbin of old ideas, replaced with sending folks to "nursing homes" and "retirement communities" with no further thought attributed to them other than obligitory holiday visits, if those are even remembered.

Some say, "I don't have time in my busy life to take care of them!" That begs the question: who will care for you in your old age?

This is a fundamental problem that the slow change in our culture from "extended family" to "nuclear family" to "individual at the expense of family" has not developed a solution for.

This is a fundamental problem that will only grow as the Baby Boomers age, regardless of any changes in Social Security or other benefits to the elderly from the government.

Think about it, and how it will affect YOU when you are old and grey.

UPDATE: I'm not trying to imply that what this woman is doing is anything remotely justified or moral, what I am trying to point out is that we have a huge number of people who soon will need some type of care, and currently we have no accepted way of paying for it if we choose nursing homes or retirement communities. What happens when there is no more money?

Posted by Jack Grant at 01:56 on 18 February 2005
Comments

I don't want my kids taking care of me... an equal trade for the fact that if I was forced to take care of my father in law, I would shoot myself. I cannot stand my father in law, yet my husband and I are the only ones who live in town.

If I were forced to take him in, I would divorce my husband and divide my family. That's how strongly I feel about it. I'm not too busy. I'm just flat out not going to do it. He's a nasty jerk. Nobody should have to deal with that.

I feel certain I'm not the only one in that boat.

Posted by: Boudicca at February 18, 2005 04:19 PM

Having worked in several nursing homes, I can tell you that most people are there because there is no way their families could care for them physically. They don't have the resources.

Back in "the day" when families would have to care for their elderly - they did it because there was no where else for them to go and it was painfully difficult for many families. There were no "nursing homes". Taking care of an elderly person with senile dementia or altzheimer's is a 24/7 job. Or a person who has been slammed by a stroke and is either bedridden or moves only with the greatest of help. It's all back breaking work. Few families have 2 adults around the clock who can trade off the duties. Fewer still have the financial wherewithal to hire nurses to come in and help.

But this woman's claim is bogus. Just because she had trouble with one nursing home doesn't mean she couldn't go to another one. She sounds like one of those people trying to work the system and get everything handed to "poor little her".

Posted by: Teresa at February 19, 2005 04:38 AM

My wee wifey cared for her mother, who neither of us liked, under our roof for several years after the old biddy had a series of debilitating strokes. In doing so she found a new calling and is now a CNA in the dementia ward. No doubt about it, this is not for everyone.

Posted by: triticale at February 21, 2005 04:28 AM




























































































































































































































































































































































This is an individual entry
if you want the main page
click below:


email me at:


Random Fate - latest posts


We don't handle randomness well.
   -Dr. Lucy Jones



Trying to hold the center in not so quiet desperation while the left and the right do their damnest to tear everything apart.


What Others Say
An American transplanted to France for the moment, Jack is sometimes conservative, sometimes liberal, and almost always right.
   -Pennywit

Jack has an impressive knowledge of history, politics, and Keanu Reeves. When it comes to pirates, Jack is waaay sexier than that pansy Dread Pirate Roberts. Oh, wait--I'm thinking of Jack Sparrow...
   -Jennifer (Jennifer's History and Stuff)


Turning and turning in the widening gyre
The falcon cannot hear the falconer;
Things fall apart; the center cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
   -William Butler Yeats, January 1919


Do not condemn the judgement of another because it differs from your own. You may both be wrong.
   -Dandemis


Wahabism Delenda Est
Wahabism must be destroyed.
-John Donovan, 12 May 2004