January 22, 2005
Recommended Reading:
An observation from Canada
By Jack GrantAlan, a Canadian, left a long, excellent comment to a post at Argghhh!, where John points to a discussion by Silfray Hraka on selective quotations. At the risk of falling prey to selectively quoting, here is the key point that I liked from the comment at Argghhh!:
There must be a better outcome than the triumph of 51% over 49%. It really can't be enough to say the 49% are now wrong anymore than that other 49% was in 1992 when your Federal goverance was reversed and the then minority was subject to ridicule. I fear, however, if the attitude of that caller is indicative of the common mood. When asked what he would give to foster greater unity he said he would give "my value to the liberals as well as a place at my church" - of course only if they would sub-ordinate themselves. Little dignity and individual autonomy in that. How would a person who saw things in the 49% be the slightest bit attracted to that pew? The core of mutual disrespect is a bad situation.In other words, if we refuse to respect those who don't see the world the same as we do, how can expect things to be any different than they are now, with little discussion but instead opponents shouting past each other, accomplishing nothing but adding noise and anger?
Read the entire comment (it's the first one after John's post), but be sure to read the discussion that John pointed to first which is also well worth reading.
Comments
Hay thanks for noticing - you may find my other manifestation at A Good Beer Blog encourages greater unity than anything I write of a political nature!
See: http://beerblog.genx40.com
Posted by: Alan at January 22, 2005 06:35 PM





