Regular readers of Random Fate have doubtless noticed I tend not to link to many other weblogs. This is not because I find little that is thought provoking out in blogworld. When I get past the usual suspects with their usually suspect opinions, there is an amazing number of posts that can provoke and fertilize thought.
Unfortunately, after an hour of reading the various opinions and thinking about the ramifications, I lose track of the 20 or 30 plus weblogs that prompt me to examine a topic and stimulate my thoughts upon it.
Also, a list of 20 or 30 links makes for unexciting reading at best.
In addition, often my thoughts are directed by music I happen to be listening to at the time I am reading and thinking. In this case, the U2 song The Hands That Built America,
written for the movie “Gangs of New York”,
caused me to consider many different topics, some that were themes of that movie and others related but only indirectly addressed in the film.
It is difficult to write upon the topic of America as an idea and an ideal without creating something that is book-length that would be read by few if any, despite the importance the subject deserves. I am forced to appeal to artists who condense a wealth of feelings into short phrases underscored by music that convey feelings so much more than volumes of mere words could ever deliver, musicians who are not even from our nation, but who illustrate what America meant to the world at large until recently:
Oh my love, it’s a long way we’ve come
From the freckled hills, to the steel and glass canyons
From the stony fields, to hanging steel from the sky
From digging in our pockets for a reason not to say goodbye
These are the hands that built America
(Russian, Sioux, Dutch, Hindu)
Oh, oh oh, America
(Polish, Irish, German, Italian)
Last saw your face in a watercolour sky
As sea birds argue, a long goodbye
I took your kiss, on the spray of the new land star
You gotta live with your dreams, don’t make them so hard
And these are the hands, that built America
(The Irish, the Blacks, the Chinese, the Jews)
Ah, ah ah, America
(Korean, Hispanic, Muslim, Indian)
Of all of the promises, is this one we could keep
Of all of the dreams, is this one still out of reach
Halle, ole
(Dream-oh-yeah)
(Oh oh-dream, oh love)
It’s early fall, there’s a cloud on the New York skyline
Innocence, dragged across a yellow line
These are the hands that built America
These are the hands that built America
Ah-ah-ah-ah-ah America
Is there any doubt that the lines, “It’s early fall, there’s a cloud on the New York skyline, Innocence, dragged across a yellow line,” refer to September 11, 2001?
Yet those are not the most important lyrics; there is far more to this song just as there is far more to America than the simplistic jingoism we have been presented with in the past half-decade by those who claim to be “leaders”.
Before that terrible day of September 11, 2001, America represented freedom and liberty both as ideas and ideals to the world, and our reactions to that day have revealed to the world the feet of clay that ideals inevitably show, yet the ideas underlying the ideals have not yet been destroyed and will not be if we choose to stand up for those ideas.
There are few things in this world in which I firmly believe, and even fewer that I am willing to stand up for. The ideas of freedom and democracy are among those precious few.
There is a critical difference between ideals and ideas.
The ideal of America has been murdered in the past five years by the actions of the government of the United States, but the ideas underlying America have not yet been destroyed.
The ideas of freedom and democracy are what I believe in. What are the gravest threats to these ideas, an external threat of terrorist organizations who kill people to get headlines, or those who claim the world changed on September 11, 2001 and say that to protect our “freedom” we must push aside the ideas of civil liberties in order to provide safety against terrorist threats?
In other words, there are those who say that we must kill the patient in order to “cure” the disease. This is a solution that appeals to the simple-minded, but not to those who truly understand the fundamentals underlying our Constitution.
What is clear to me is that which is the true threat, and that threat is NOT the one commonly perceived.
It is often quoted, by me as much as by others, something that was written by one of my heroes, Benjamin Franklin, “They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.”
Those who proclaim “the world changed on 9/11″ as an argument towards undermining the freedoms we had against government surveillance of our lives understand neither the nature of the world before September 11, 2001, nor do they understand the foundations underlying our Constitution.
These misunderstandings are so basic that I must question whether either these people did not have the Civics class that was required of all 9th-graders when I went to school, or they deliberately choose to ignore our fundamental ideals in a quest to claim and proclaim approval for the actions of the current administration, which are questionable at best on Constitutional grounds, even if supposed good intentions are included in the calculus.
What are the fundamentals?
The Founders had recently overcome, at the time they wrote our Constitution, through actions that included secret meetings and covert actions against the legitimate government of their lands, a government that claimed to have the power to inspect any private home or other property without any restraint. Abuse of this power was the rationale behind the requirement to have judicial review and approval of search warrants.
Yet, somehow, after more than 200 years of survival, the actions of a few fanatics on September 11, 2001, are a justification to many, not solely members of the current Bush administration but apparently including many in America as a whole if comments are to be relied upon, that the philosophy that has survived 200-plus years should be cast aside because “the world changed on 9/11.”
As I have written before, many times, the world did not change on 9/11/2001, only our perception of the world changed.
We, the United States, had been attacked several times before 9/11/2001, but we didn’t notice because either the attacks did not succeed (the earlier attempts to bring down the World Trade Center in New York by truck-bombs in the parking garage), or only foreigners were killed (the car-bomb attacks on embassies in Africa).
We only panicked when the deaths were those in the United States itself. Now in the “land of the free and the home of the brave” as we so proudly proclaim in our national anthem we shit in our pants and give up yet another essential liberty every time the administration cries “terrorist” or bin Laden issues another taped proclamation.
Do your own math, but it easily comes out to this: So much for being brave OR free…
Actions speak louder than words.
Through our actions we show who we really are, regardless of any ideas we claim to follow.
One could easily cry “hypocrisy” when we have no care for those who die in our attacks on al-Qaida targets in other nations such as Pakistan where foreigners are killed, because we can ease our conscience by saying “they must have been supporters of the terrorists because they were nearby,” neglecting the truth that we have no idea what our own next-door neighbors do (the “he was such an ordinary person” comments of the neighbors of serial killers should give us SOME kind of clue you would think…).
America was once the ideal of the world when it came to freedom. As a result of the actions of the government of the United States in the past five years, we have shown our feet of clay, whether in “extraordinary rendition” or the scandals of Abu Ghirab and Guantanamo or the warrantless wiretaps recently come to light.
Apologists of the current administration like to claim that the views of the world outside America do not matter.
They are wrong.
Once is happenstance.
Twice is coincidence.
Three times…
…perhaps a closer look is required.
The United States of America won the Cold War mainly because it stood as an ideal to the rest of the world for freedom and democracy.
Our reaction to the attacks of September 11, 2001, and the ephemeral, non-existential threat they pose illustrate in no uncertain terms how hollow that ideal is, showing the feet of clay that any hero ultimately reveals.
However, America still represents the idea of freedom, unless we squander that legacy as well.
It is up to us to see whether we keep alive the idea after, through our actions, we have destroyed the image of America as the ideal.